Differing Perspectives: 3 Tips Towards a Creative Business Debate

By Janet Sernack

29 May 2012 | No Comments

sharing creative business ideas

One of the key comfort zone points that I developed as a result of spending most of my adult life in Australia, is to not ‘rock the boat’, or ‘make waves.’

Let’s take a moment to consider the whole subject of ‘debate’, and how it gets typically gets played out in Australia. In high school, debate tends to be perceived as a ‘contest’, or a ‘competition’, with ‘winners’ and ‘losers’. Each team represents a point of view and elegantly puts forward their case ‘for it’ or ‘against it’, the team with the ‘best’ or most convincing case, according to the judging panel, wins!

Even Australian governments debate their laws and policies, with each political party taking ‘sides’, playing this ‘win/lose’ and ‘denial/blame’ games. Even the language, ‘in opposition’ supports what is considered to be a very limited ‘right/wrong’ way of seeing the world.

In most organisations I have consulted to, in my 30 plus years of corporate experience, where ‘right/wrong’ perspectives thrive, it has now become culturally incorrect to be challenging, argumentative or ‘oppositional’. Conflict is avoided at all costs, and debates have become very polite and even tempered conversations. I have noticed that very few people seem to have the energy, confidence and the courage to really challenge the status quo.

The problem with this approach is that it eliminates possibilities, breakthroughs and creative ideas and inhibits innovation.

It seems that we no longer know how to be appropriately assertive and challenging in our communications. This hesitation and politeness creates a range of passive, frustrated and conventional responses to the questions that get asked. What is needed for innovation to occur is an active debate process that generates higher level ideas, not one which seeks to make one party ‘wrong’ and the other ‘right’.

Some of the world’s most successful entrepreneurs deal with threats, instability and uncertainty, by taking a position of being consciously ‘in opposition’; to the organisation, its identity and deeply resisted complacency.

Successful entrepreneurs have developed unique ways of doing this that stimulates and generates ‘out of the box’ answers and unconventional solutions. They do this in ways that do not cause aggressive or passive defensive responses. Ideas and perspectives get challenged, dismissed and reinvented until high levels of ‘meta thinking’ are achieved.

Finally, generative debating has the power to be intentionally ‘disruptive’, which creates mindset shifts and generates innovative solutions, ideas and perspectives to problems that may have previously seemed impossible and insolvable.

So, if you would like to get the ball rolling to include more debate into your business: ask more questions, especially open and exploratory ones that don’t minimise and disengage the person you are interacting with:

  1. What would happen if...............? Pause and listen for their response. Keep on repeating the question until Meta thinking levels are achieved.
  2. Accept every suggestion someone presents, even if you don’t agree by stating “yes......... and....” Pause and listen for their response.
  3. When someone makes a suggestion, reply with “I like ...............and what if we....................” Pause and listen for their response. Repeat first question.

You may be surprised by the possibilities and opportunities that get generated when you accept differing perspectives!

Janet Sernack, ImagineNation


Janet Sernack, ImagineNation

Janet Sernack

Janet has recently created an exciting new start-up company called ImagineNation, an imaginative, deviant and disruptive global learning consultancy that allows coaches, leaders, and organisations to dance in dis-equilibrium that occurs at the edge of chaos. At ImagineNation, we make innovation ever...

Read more about Janet Sernack

See all by Janet Sernack

More by Janet Sernack

How to Make Your Big Idea Really Happen!

All great achievers start out as individuals with a vision that ultimately impacts the realms they care about! They may not initially intend to, they have the ability to shape an entire industry or market. A relevant and stunningly successful example is how Suzi Dafnis took a leadership position and advanced The Australian Businesswomen’s Network and progressed [...]

Read More

Managing Your "CDs" or “The Creeping Doubts”

Whether we admit it, or not, at some stage or another in our business development cycle, we have all experienced a serious, crippling or even a paralysing case of the “CDs” or “The Creeping Doubts”. These can manifest at any time, it could have been when you started your business, and felt overwhelmed by “The [...]

Read More

Developing a winning edge!

Whether you have developed a product or service business, if you don’t innovate, eventually you will disappear. Competition is intensifying and most companies are fighting to retain their market positions and customer loyalty, making innovation a ‘must have’, just to stay in business! If you want to succeed and grow your business further, you will [...]

Read More

Why Entrepreneurs are Lucky!

During the fourth round of The Start-Up Game™, a business simulation that fosters innovation and entrepreneurship, players are required to randomly select a number of boxes on a digitised screen. Depending on their “luck”, their choice of boxes will result on one of three options: they will increase the monetary value of their Start-Up, they [...]

Read More

Managing Your Emotions When Frustrated and Overwhelmed!

Most people can agree that creating a new website is possibly one of the most challenging activities a small business person ever undertakes. There are so many aspects to consider, including creativity, functionality, content, key words, search engine maximisation, costs and timing, just to name a few. I recently discovered that finding one service provider [...]

Read More

Be-ing a Successful, Innovative and Entrepreneurial Leader

Having spent the last two years researching and deciphering what it takes to be a successful entrepreneur and how to BE innovative as the basis for inventing my own new start-up company, www.imaginenation.co.il, I learned that there are three distinct phases an entrepreneur must master to successfully invent a radically new business! Whilst it seems [...]

Read More

How can you be a more successful business entrepreneur?

One of my clients recently decided that it was time re-invent both herself and her business. She realised that she had fallen into the ‘ME-TOO’ trap, not only that she was quietly bored with what she was doing, she found that her business was essentially just as ‘ME-TOO’ as all the others in her market [...]

Read More

How Healthy is Your Organisational Culture?

No matter how many businesses I have worked with as a business consultant, whether it is a very small company or a large corporation, the business always seems to reflect the personality of its owner, CEO or leadership team. Sometimes that demonstrates a very healthy and constructive culture and sometimes it can be a very [...]

Read More

How to Be an Extraordinary Leader!

Wouldn't the world be a different place if we could all be even just a bit more extraordinary? One of my colleagues, the CEO of a global NGO, shared with me recently the most fascinating thing she learned from reading Steve Jobs' biography: “Quite fascinating, he talks a lot about his 'reality distortion field' that [...]

Read More

In what ways are you controlling and/or shaping your business efforts?

One of the key challenges that constantly confronts small business owners is finding the fine line between trying to be in control of everything that goes on in the business and then being flexible and adaptive enough to still, intentionally, shape its direction. It’s both/and! Whilst effective management requires us to plan and to install [...]

Read More